new haven schull The Palestinian Return and Right of Return—No Deal! (journal article)



Zeitgeist
Events around date of publication of this item.
Show later events
Tue, 8 Jul 2008
Israeli occupation forces invade several towns in West Bank; kidnap and harass Palestinian civilians
Mon, 7 Jul 2008
Israeli Lt-Colonel pushes blindfolded handcuffed Palestinian demonstrator into place, so that he can be shot at point-blank range
Sat, 5 Jul 2008
Israeli settlers tie a Palestinian man to an electricity pole in the West Bank and then kick him as Israeli soldiers stood idly by
end of Israeli occupation forces invade Kifl Hares and put it under curfew to enable a "settler pilgrimage"
Fri, 4 Jul 2008
end of Israeli occupation forces invade several West Bank towns; harass and kidnap Palestinian civilians
Thu, 3 Jul 2008
Israeli police and military violently harass Palestinian residents of the Old City of Jerusalem
start of Israeli occupation forces invade Kifl Hares and put it under curfew to enable a "settler pilgrimage"
Wed, 2 Jul 2008
start of Israeli occupation forces invade several West Bank towns; harass and kidnap Palestinian civilians
Bulldozer rampage in Jerusalem
Tue, 1 Jul 2008
Israeli death squad targets resistance leader in the village of Qabatiya
Israeli occupation forces invade several West Bank villages; harass and kidnap Palestinian civilians
end of Israeli occupation forces invade the village of Deir Abu Mishal; harass and menace Palestinian civilians
Mon, 30 Jun 2008
start of Israeli occupation forces invade the village of Deir Abu Mishal; harass and menace Palestinian civilians
Sat, 28 Jun 2008
Israeli occupation forces attack mourning funeral procession in Beit Omer
Fri, 27 Jun 2008
Israeli occupation forces invade Beit Omer; kill, wound and kidnap Palestinian civilians
Thu, 26 Jun 2008
Israeli occupation forces invade Nablus and harass and kidnap Palestinian civilians
Mohammed Omer tortured by Shin Bet officers at the Allenby crossing
Wed, 25 Jun 2008
Israeli occupation forces harass several West Bank towns and kidnap Palestinian civilians
Tue, 24 Jun 2008
US secretary of state suggests that Palestinian refugees should settle in South America
Passage of H.Con.Res.362 where the US Congress calls on the US to toughen sanctions on Iran

Show earlier events

The Palestinian Return and Right of Return—No Deal!

<<< Earlier issue of this journal ^ This issue of this journal (1 other article) Later issue of this journal >>>

Article/book #: 86046
Title: The Palestinian Return and Right of Return—No Deal!
By: Michael Warschawski  
Published in: Alternative Information Center
Date of issue: Wednesday, 2 July 2008
Topic(s) addressed:
Commentary

Abstract:

Before dealing with the topic of the Palestinian refugees and the Right of Return, I would like to say a few words following the interesting remarks of my friend Omar Barghouti on the issue of “one democratic state.” In my opinion, the core of our discussions should not be about solutions and models, but values and rights. In that perspective, one has to unequivocally reject the very idea (and existence) of a Jewish state, whatever will be its borders. For a Jewish state (in the demographic sense of the concept) necessarily implies the drive for exclusion and expulsion. Any ethnic (or confessional) state considers the non-dominant ethnicity as a threat, and aspires to its disappearance through more or less violent means. As former Yugoslavia and Rwanda have tragically shown, ethnic states are always both the cause and the result of mass-expulsions and massacres, and the ethnic cleansing of Palestine in 1947-1949 is one among many examples of that historical phenomenon.

Our conception of democracy is based on a state of and for all its citizens (and refugees), with no discrimination based on ethnic, national or religious belonging, a state where all the cultural or national groups comprising its society are treated in an equal manner.

Ultimately, a Jewish state is also a tragedy for the Israeli Jews, as it implies a closed society, doomed to decline as all closed societies throughout history. The development of civilizations has always been the result of openness, inter-and multi-culturalism and exchange. Moreover, the drive to maintain the “ethnic purity” of its state renders the Israeli society a paranoid entity. Fighting the “Jewish State” conception and institutions is a duty, independent of the political structure of the solution we defend.

Let’s address the issue of the Right of Return, the core issue of the so-called Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

In the last decade, a new approach to deal with the issue of Palestinian refugees has been suggested, primarily by the Zionist Left. It is a sort of compromise based on the separation between the Right of Return and the actual return of refugees. According to this “compromise,” Israel will repent its sins of 1948 and formally recognize the Right of Return of the Refugees, and, in exchange, the Palestinians will renounce their Right of Return. What a deal!










Previous Next